"The best investment our company has made on analytics" - Benzapp, Bob Martin

How to Create Effective Calls-to-Action for Conversion Rate Optimization

Aug 14, 2023 | TIPS & TOOLS

In the vast world of digital marketing, there’s one element that reigns supreme when driving user engagement: the Call-to-Action (CTA). In fact, a powerful CTA can be the backbone of your conversion rate optimization strategy. But crafting one that truly resonates and compels users isn’t a mere walk in the park. It’s a blend of psychology, design, and strategic positioning. So, join us as we explain how to create effective calls-to-action for conversion rate optimization by providing you with the top 13 ways to go about this.

Understand Your Audience’s Motivations

Before crafting that perfect CTA, it’s paramount to understand who you’re speaking to. What drives them? What are their pain points and desires? Answering these questions can offer a clearer picture of how to position your CTA.

Empathy is Key: Put yourself in your user’s shoes. Understand their journey, from the challenges they face to the solutions they seek.

Segmentation: Not every CTA will resonate with every user. Segmenting your audience and tailoring your CTAs can yield more personalized and, therefore, more effective results.

Evoke Emotion with Powerful Language

Words are powerful, and in the digital realm, they can be the catalyst for action. Hence, your choice of verbiage can make or break your CTA.

Action Words: Begin with verbs that urge action, like “Discover,” “Learn,” or “Get Started.”

Convey Urgency: Phrases like “Limited Time Offer” or “Only a Few Left” can create a sense of scarcity, prompting users to act promptly.

Reassure: Users need to feel secure. Words like “Guaranteed” or “Risk-Free” can instill confidence.

Amplify with Stellar Design

While words can ignite action, design can amplify that spark. Therefore, an effective CTA isn’t just about the message; it’s about how that message is presented.

Contrasting Colors: The key point is that your CTA should be noticeable. Using contrasting colors can make it stand out and draw the user’s attention.

Size Matters: Too big, and it may be overwhelming, but too small, and it might go unnoticed. Find the sweet spot for your CTA button size.

Whitespace: Giving your CTA some breathing room can accentuate its importance, ensuring it isn’t lost amidst other page elements.

Strategic Positioning for Maximum Impact

Did you know that where your CTA sits can influence its effectiveness? It’s true! While there’s no one-size-fits-all approach, here are some tested strategies that can guide your placement.

Above the Fold: Placing CTAs here ensures visibility when a user lands on your page.

End of Content: After consuming your content, users might be looking for the next step. Here’s where your CTA can guide them.

Floating or Sticky CTAs: These remain visible as users scroll, providing constant prompts to take action.

Offer Value, Not Just Commands

Let’s be honest for a second – users are inundated with CTAs everywhere they go online. To stand out, offer unmistakable value.

Tangible Benefits: Instead of just saying “Subscribe,” how about “Get Exclusive Tips Directly to Your Inbox”?

Clear Outcomes: Let users know exactly what to expect. If it’s a free eBook, say so. If it’s a monthly newsletter, make it clear.

A/B Test Relentlessly

Even with all these strategies, there’s no definitive guarantee of what will work best for your specific audience. Enter the power of A/B testing.

Varying Designs: Test different colors, sizes, and fonts to see what resonates the most.

Positional Testing: Move your CTAs around. The results might surprise you.

Alter Verbiage: Sometimes, a slight tweak in wording can make a world of difference.

Feedback Loop

Engage with your audience and gather feedback. Sometimes, direct insights from users can shed light on areas of improvement that may not be immediately obvious.

Surveys and Feedback Forms: Allow users to share their thoughts on your CTAs.

Analytics: Dive deep into CTA click-through rates and conversion metrics to gauge effectiveness.

Mobile Optimization

With a substantial chunk of web traffic coming from mobile devices, ensuring your CTAs are optimized for mobile viewing is no longer optional; it’s imperative.

Responsive Design: Ensure your CTAs adjust well to varying screen sizes.

Thumb-friendly: On mobile, CTAs should be easily clickable with a thumb.

Utilize Persuasive Visual Elements

Images and symbols can amplify the appeal of your CTA, guiding the user’s eye and enhancing comprehension.

Icons & Symbols: Use universally recognized icons that align with your message, such as a download icon for downloadable content.

Relevant Imagery: Images can evoke emotions, so an image that matches the theme of your CTA can increase its appeal.

Reduce Friction Points

Any barriers, perceived or real, can deter users from taking action. Hence, it’s vital to minimize these obstacles.

Limit Form Fields: If your CTA leads to a form, only ask for essential information.

Reassurance on Click: If users know what to expect after clicking, they’re more likely to engage. For instance, use “Watch Video” instead of a vague “Click Here.”

Leverage Social Proof

Users often rely on others’ decisions to guide their actions. Harness this behavioral tendency to enhance CTA effectiveness.

Testimonials: Including a short testimonial near a CTA can increase trustworthiness.

Numbers: Displaying the number of people who’ve already taken action can motivate others. For example, “Join 10,000 subscribers!”

Focus on Accessibility

Ensure everyone, including users with disabilities, can easily interact with your CTA.

Color Contrast: Make sure there’s enough contrast between your CTA button and its background for those with visual impairments.

Keyboard Navigation: Your CTA should be easily navigable using keyboard shortcuts for those who can’t use a mouse.

Use Time-sensitive Offers

As we mentioned earlier, limited-time offers can create urgency, motivating users to act faster.

Countdown Timers: Displaying a visible timer counting down can drive immediate action.

Date Stamps: Indicating when an offer ends, like “Sale Ends on August 20th!” can spur users into action, fearing they might miss out.

Wrapping Up: The Power of the CTA

At the end of the day, crafting effective calls-to-action for conversion rate optimization is a blend of art and science. It’s about resonating with your audience, standing out in a sea of digital prompts, and constantly evolving based on insights and data. Remember, a stellar CTA is more than just a button – it’s a bridge, guiding users from interest to desired action. And with the right strategies in place, you can ensure that bridge leads to conversion success!


We hope you enjoyed reading this blog post

If you'd like our team at Digital Dames to help you massively improve website traffic and conversions, just book a call.

Post Contributors

Jaclyn Hawtin

Jaclyn Hawtin

Director of Technology

Over a decade of experience in product management, devops, startups, and agile methodologies. Track record of simplifying complex technical processes for cross-functional teams. Proficient in user centered design, UX, IX, UI, IA, user research and data analytics for responsive web, mobile and tablet applications. Incredibly adaptable, fluent with both people and machines.

Mani O'Brien

Mani O'Brien

Director of Marketing

Mani is a senior marketing manager with roots in storytelling. She nerds out on everything data, technology, human behavior and design. Chat with her about UX/UI, marketing funnels, conversion and goal tracking, marketing experimentation and astrology (she’s a Virgo Sun, Aries Rising).

Most Read
Analyzing Your Conversion Funnel to Increase Conversion Rates

Analyzing Your Conversion Funnel to Increase Conversion Rates

Every day, countless visitors navigate your website, yet only a fraction convert into tangible sales, registrations, or interactions. By understanding and analyzing your conversion funnel, you can pinpoint where potential customers drop off and fine-tune their journey...

Developing an Effective Landing Page for Improved Conversion Rates

Developing an Effective Landing Page for Improved Conversion Rates

Did you know that developing an effective landing page is crucial for achieving improved conversion rates? It's true! Unlike regular web pages, landing pages have a specific purpose: to encourage visitors to complete a particular goal. And the fact is, whether you're...

Understanding Your Customer Journey to Improve Conversion Rates

Understanding Your Customer Journey to Improve Conversion Rates

In today's competitive business landscape, understanding your customer journey is crucial for optimizing conversion rates. The customer journey refers to the path that a customer takes from the moment they become aware of your brand to the point of making a purchase...

How to Utilize User Generated Content to Increase Conversion Rates

How to Utilize User Generated Content to Increase Conversion Rates

In today's digital landscape, businesses are constantly seeking innovative ways to increase conversion rates and foster meaningful connections with their target audience. One powerful strategy that has gained traction is leveraging user-generated content (UGC)....

Free Analytics 101 Course

Sign up for free access to start your data journey

First Name
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Conversion Path Ep. 12 -- Shopify Conversion Tips With Guest Brad Redding from Elevar Ep. 12 -- Shopify Conversion Tips With Guest Brad Redding from Elevar More