Is SEO Worth it?

Jan 14, 2022 | TIPS & TOOLS

Is SEO Worth it for Small Businesses?

Marketing budgets are under intense scrutiny right now, as businesses around the world and in a range of sectors tighten their belts. If you are involved in digital marketing, you need to be able to demonstrate the value of the different aspects of your role – including search engine optimization. How do you show the return on investment for SEO though? How can you prove unequivocally that it is worth the time and expense?

Read on, and we will show you!

Ask yourself one fundamental question

Any analysis of the value of SEO should begin with one basic question:

What is an improvement in your search engine ranking worth to your business, brand, or product?

Now, this question might seem like it is subjective, and thus does not have any value to a conversation about proving value – but it can be explicitly quantified.

What are higher search engine rankings worth?

You can use an easy equation (we promise to keep the math simple) to work out the value of an increase in your search engine ranking. What you do is: take the keyword search volume, the expected click-through, the average conversions rate, and the average order value, and multiply them together, like this:

Keyword search volume x expected click-through x average conversion x average order value

Then, you take that figure and compare it to the investment in SEO – you should now have two dollar amounts, the outgoing investment, and the incoming orders as a result of that investment. As with any cost analysis – you want the income to exceed the expense.

That might seem a bit abstract and hard to follow, so let’s put that equation to work in a real-world situation: something that we know a little about, a digital marketing agency.

Using ahrefs.com (an SEO analysis tool, you can use your preferred provider) gives us an average search volume for the phrase ‘digital marketing company’ of 900 – meaning this term is typically searched for around 900 times per month. This is the first figure for the above equation.

To find expected click-through rates, we turn to Google, or at least an analysis of Google, like this one. Click through rates for the first page of Google results on an organic search are listed as follows:

Rank 1 36.5% click-through
Rank 2 12.5% click-through
Rank 3 9.5% click-through
Rank 4 7.9% click-through
Rank 5 6.1% click-through
Rank 6 4.1% click-through
Rank 7 3.8% click-through
Rank 8 3.5% click-through
Rank 9 3.0% click-through
Rank 10 2.2% click-through
Rank 11-16 1.5% click-through
Rank 17-50 0.3% click-through

The number on the right in the table is the second figure for use in the calculation. As an aside, that table alone should be a good demonstration of the value of SEO – the drop-off between the first-ranked and the tenth-ranked results is huge!

The third and fourth parts of the equation depend on your organization – your sales team, web team, or finance team should have those figures to hand relatively easily. For the sake of the example, let us say that our digital marketing agency has a conversion rate of 2% of the visitors to the website, with an order value averaging $2,000.

So, for the first ranked position when a search for ‘digital marketing agency’ is conducted, we get this:

900 searches x 36.5% click-through x 2% conversion x $2000 spend = $13140

That means that $13,140 is the average expected income if you were ranked number 1 for the search ‘digital marketing company’.

That’s the ideal situation from your SEO – ranking number one. Let’s assume though, that for the time being you are not number one, and let’s say that you are currently number 20.

That equation then looks like this:

900 searches x 0.3% click-through x 2% conversion x $2000 value = $108

So you are bringing in an average of $108 per month by way of organic searches for ‘digital marketing company’.

It is obvious, then, that ranking number one is massively better for income than ranking number 20 – but there is one final factor to consider…

How much does it cost to improve search engine ranking?

Once again in our hypothetical world, let us say that you spend $2,000 per month on SEO – whether internally or with a specialist search engine optimization consultant. Over the course of a year, you might reasonably expect to gradually move up the rankings to number 3, following this approximate path:

Month 1

Rank 20

$108 value

Month 2

Rank 19

$108 value

Month 3

Rank 17

$108 value

Month 4

Rank 16

$540 value

Month 5

Rank 12

$540 value

Month 6

Rank 10

$792 value

Month 7

Rank 9

$1080 value

Month 8

Rank 7

$1368 value

Month 9

Rank 5

$2196 value

Month 10

Rank 5

$2196 value

Month 11

Rank 4

$3420 value

Month 12

Rank 3

$3420 value

This gives us an income for the year of $15,876, against an outlay of $24,000 ($2,000 per month, for a year). Obviously, this is a loss – but the story does not end there. In year two, you gradually work your way up to number one, on this trajectory:

Month 13

Rank 3

$3420 value

Month 14

Rank 3

$3420 value

Month 15

Rank 3

$3420 value

Month 16

Rank 3

$3420 value

Month 17

Rank 2

$4500 value

Month 18

Rank 2

$4500 value

Month 19

Rank 2

$4500 value

Month 20

Rank 2

$4500 value

Month 21

Rank 2

$4500 value

Month 22

Rank 2

$4500 value

Month 23

Rank 1

$13140 value

Month 24

Rank 1

$13140 value

Year 2 income then, is $66,960, against a consistent cost of $24,000. That gives us a profit over the two years (negating the loss in year 1), and we are better positioned moving into year 3 and onwards.

What does this mean for your business?

These figures are an example, so to find out if SEO is worth it for your business, with your keywords, your average conversion, and your average order value, you need to enter those figures into the calculation and run the numbers. You will soon see the approximate return on investment, and be able to make an informed, data-driven decision.

Check out Digital Dames SEO serivce packages. We’d love to help you run these calculations for your organization. 

We hope you enjoyed reading this blog post

If you’d like our team at Digital Dames to help you massively improve website traffic and conversions, just book a call.

Post Contributors

Jaclyn Hawtin

Jaclyn Hawtin

Senior Data Architect

Over a decade of experience in product management, devops, startups, and agile methodologies. Track record of simplifying complex technical processes for cross-functional teams. Proficient in user centered design, UX, IX, UI, IA, user research and data analytics for responsive web, mobile and tablet applications. Incredibly adaptable, fluent with both people and machines.

Mani O'Brien

Mani O'Brien

Conversion optimization manager

Mani is a senior marketing manager with roots in storytelling. She nerds out on everything data, technology, human behavior and design. Chat with her about UX/UI, marketing funnels, conversion and goal tracking, marketing experimentation and astrology (she’s a Virgo Sun, Aries Rising).

Most Read
How much does app ux/ui design cost?

How much does app ux/ui design cost?

Sooo... How much does app ux/ui design really cost? Design (UI/UX) development is one of the most critical parts of a successful mobile app. Beautiful and pleasant screen designs, clean buttons, and strategically placed visual effects evoke positive emotions from...

Black Lives Matter. The Ways We Commit to Antiracism as a Company

Black Lives Matter. The Ways We Commit to Antiracism as a Company

At Digital Dames we believe that Black Lives Matter. We have always held women, minorities and otherwise disenfranchised communities near to our hearts as we grow this company. With that, we recognize that there is much unlearning to do in order to unpack our own...

Mobile App Marketing: iOS 14.5 Apple’s App Tracking Transparency

Mobile App Marketing: iOS 14.5 Apple’s App Tracking Transparency

Mobile App Marketing: The Impact of iOS 14.5 Apple App Tracking Transparency Wow! Apple has rolled out its new privacy/consent updates with iOS 14.5 giving consumers more control over what data they share with mobile apps. What does this mean for mobile app marketing?...

What Is a Good eCommerce Conversion Rate?

What Is a Good eCommerce Conversion Rate?

What Is a Good eCommerce Conversion Rate? Are you looking at your conversion rates for landing pages and your eCommerce site overall wondering if they are good enough? You’re not the only one! The majority of eCommerce business owners have a conversion rate they would...